Education is the primary mechanism through which individuals and communities acquire the knowledge, skills, and moral character necessary for equitable social participation. When the integrity of that process is subverted, the consequences are social and ethical as well as academic. Academic dishonesty refers to any deliberate act through which a student misrepresents their own learning or secures an unfair advantage in an assessment, encompassing copying, unauthorised materials, impersonation, collusion, plagiarism, unauthorised device use, and advance access to examination material (Anderman & Murdock, 2007; Cizek, 2003). The problem is confined to no single country: Cizek (2003) identified examination fraud as persistent across diverse national contexts, and its prevalence has since been documented from sub-Saharan Africa (Dejene, 2021) to South Asia (Nazir et al., 2011). Across these settings the same convergence recurs of certification culture, peer normalisation, and institutional under-resourcing. What is less consistent is the response: counselling interventions designed specifically to address academic dishonesty remain rare, and the evidence base is thin outside Western contexts (Anyamene et al., 2015; Tamami et al., 2015). This study contributes to closing that gap.
In Nigeria, the problem has reached proportions that demand systemic analysis. Aderinto et al. (2021) found that 62% of the Nigerian secondary school students surveyed had engaged in some form of examination misconduct before graduating. The scale is also visible in official examination data: in the 2026 West African Senior School Certificate Examination, the West African Examinations Council (WAEC) withheld 167,486 results, 8.59% of the 1,950,726 candidates, on grounds of suspected malpractice (International Centre for Investigative Reporting, 2026). In WAEC’s May/June 2022 examinations, school principals were themselves indicted for complicity in organised malpractice (Adebayo, 2022). Malpractice on this scale is not a matter of isolated individual misconduct; it indicates a normalised crisis.
Academic dishonesty is typically framed as an individual behavioural problem. That framing is inadequate and, I argue, itself a form of injustice: it absolves institutions, communities, and policymakers of their role in creating the conditions that make dishonesty appear rational. Where classrooms are overcrowded, teachers demoralised, certification prized above competence, detection mechanisms weak, and peer networks tolerant, dishonesty becomes structurally encouraged rather than merely individually chosen (Diego, 2017; Eckstein, 2003; Isiaka, 2025). Each element of this account has independent empirical support, reviewed below in “The Social Ecology of Academic Dishonesty”. These conditions, acute in Nigeria, are an extreme expression of pressures present in varying degrees across school systems globally.
The social justice implications are considerable. Academically honest students compete on an unequal footing, employers receive graduates whose credentials misrepresent competence, individuals with partially fabricated qualifications enter professions such as medicine and law, and public trust in credentials erodes (Cizek, 2003; Dimpka, 2011).
Against this backdrop, school counsellors occupy a strategically important position, operating at the intersection of individual psychology and community norms. This is not an assertion original to this paper. Bemak and Chung (2008) argued that counsellors who confine themselves to individual remedial support are complicit in the systemic conditions generating the difficulties they treat, and the American Counselling Association (ACA) Advocacy Competencies locate legitimate counsellor activity at the community collaboration, systems advocacy, and public information levels as well as the individual one (Ratts et al., 2010; Toporek et al., 2009). Within that framework, counsellors deploying group interventions against the distortions and norms sustaining dishonesty can be described as performing social action rather than merely treating a behavioural problem. This paper offers preliminary empirical evidence and a theoretical framework in support of that claim.
Hypotheses
The study was guided by three null hypotheses, each tested at the .05 level of significance. They are stated here in full so that the results reported below can be read directly against them.
H01: There is no significant difference in the post-test mean scores on proneness to academic dishonesty among in-school adolescents exposed to psychoeducation, cognitive restructuring, and the control condition.
H02: There is no significant difference in the post-test mean scores on academic self-efficacy among in-school adolescents exposed to psychoeducation, cognitive restructuring, and the control condition.
H03: There is no significant gender difference in the post-test mean scores on proneness to academic dishonesty or academic self-efficacy among in-school adolescents across the treatment and control groups.
The Social Ecology of Academic Dishonesty: A Framework With Global Resonance
Understanding academic dishonesty as social action begins with its ecology. The frame adopted here is broadly Bronfenbrennerian: behaviour arises within nested systems running from the peer and classroom microsystem, through the school and family mesosystem and the examination and policy exosystem, to the cultural macrosystem in which certification acquires meaning (Bronfenbrenner, 1979). Locating dishonesty across these levels identifies where a counsellor can realistically intervene and where change depends on others. Eckstein (2003) identified a convergence of societal pressure, institutional weakness, and inadequate enforcement that sustains examination fraud, and this convergence is not geographically bounded. Similar drivers have been documented among Ethiopian secondary students (Dejene, 2021), in Southeast Asian classrooms (Diego, 2017), in Gulf contexts (Al-Dossary, 2017), and in North Africa (Hammoudi & Benzerroug, 2021). The structural ecology of dishonesty appears cross-contextual rather than culturally specific, and in Nigeria these forces are particularly acute.
At the societal level, certification is valued as a primary marker of achievement, often independently of the competence it is meant to represent. Al-Dossary (2017) found favourable attitudes towards dishonesty among students who prioritise grades over learning, reinforced by family and teacher expectations. Parents who press for success without emphasising the means may foster a family environment in which dishonesty comes to appear a rational response (Hammoudi & Benzerroug, 2021; Lang, 2013).
At the institutional level, Nigerian public secondary schools face chronic under-resourcing: too few teachers, poor examination infrastructure, and authorities judged on results rather than process integrity. These conditions may generate structural opportunities for malpractice. Eckstein (2003) documented how leakage of examination material, often facilitated by bribery, becomes endemic where enforcement is weak. Severity varies, but the underlying dynamic of institutional incentives misaligned with integrity is recognisable well beyond Nigeria (Cizek, 2003).
At the peer and classroom level, Social Cognitive Theory (Bandura, 1977) supplies the explanatory framework. Students who observe peers acting dishonestly without consequence receive direct observational evidence that dishonesty is viable and safe. As Bandura (2008) argued, people learn and regulate behaviour through vicarious experience: witnessing dishonesty go unpunished may raise a student’s confidence that they too can succeed by those means. This is the social transmission mechanism at the heart of the problem, and it operates wherever students can observe one another’s academic conduct and its consequences.
Personal variables compound this ecology. Low academic self-efficacy is a consistent predictor of dishonesty: students who doubt their ability to succeed legitimately are likelier to seek shortcuts (Murdock et al., 2001; Pratiwi, 2014; Umaru, 2013). Procrastination and an external locus of control have been implicated alongside it (Anyanwu, 2020; Arifah et al., 2018; Isiaka et al., 2024; Novita & Jannah, 2022; Rinn et al., 2014). This study measures self-efficacy rather than these other factors, since it is the construct both interventions address most directly and the one Social Cognitive Theory identifies as the proximal regulator of behavioural choice. The evidence above comes from the United States, Nigeria, and Indonesia—systems differing substantially in resourcing, assessment stakes, and cultural composition. Convergent findings across them suggest these countries’ correlations are not narrowly culture-bound, although the range sampled remains limited and the claim is advanced as reasonably supported rather than established.
This ecological reading carries a clear implication for counselling: interventions addressing individual attitudes alone, without targeting the norms, distortions, and skill deficits that sustain dishonesty, will achieve limited impact. Effective work requires a group format that simultaneously challenges cognition, builds alternative skills, and shifts the peer normative environment. Why such interventions might travel across contexts is worth stating plainly: their transferability rests less on the similarity of educational systems than on the generality of the processes they target. Cognitive distortion, efficacy belief, and observational learning are proposed within their parent theories as basic psychological processes rather than culturally specific ones. That generality is a matter of degree rather than of kind; the qualifications it carries are set out below in “Theoretical Foundations for Counsellor-Led Social Action” and the adaptation requirements in “Transferability and Implications for School Counsellors Globally”.
Theoretical Foundations for Counsellor-Led Social Action
Two frameworks underpin both the intervention design and the social action framing: Cognitive Behavioural Theory (CBT) and Social Cognitive Theory (SCT). These are not merely explanatory models; they are the theoretical backbone of recognised school counselling practice. CBT-based techniques, cognitive restructuring and psychoeducation among them, are among the most extensively validated approaches in the school counselling literature (Christner et al., 2007), and SCT has long informed how counsellors understand the relational and environmental conditions shaping student behaviour (Borders & Drury, 1992).
CBT holds that thoughts, emotions, and behaviours are dynamically interrelated (Beck, 2011). Distortions such as rationalisation (“everyone cheats”), minimisation (“it’s only a small test”), and blame-shifting (“the system is unfair”) sustain maladaptive behaviour, and change comes through identifying, challenging, and reframing them. CBT underpins the cognitive restructuring (CR) intervention here, giving students techniques to recognise their own rationalisation patterns and replace them with reality-based alternatives (Clark, 2014; Ghamari-Kivi et al., 2015). This approach suits group delivery in schools because its structured, skills-based format is accessible to adolescents, fits school timetables, and builds transferable tools rather than therapeutic dependency (Stallard, 2002). The counsellor deploying CR functions not as a clinician treating pathology but as a skills educator building cognitive capacity.
SCT (Bandura, 1977) supplies the social dimension through its proposition that behaviour is the product of reciprocal interaction between personal factors, behaviour, and environment. Three constructs matter here:
-
Observational learning: students learn whether dishonesty is acceptable by watching what happens to peers who cheat (Bandura, 2008), so a counsellor convening a structured group is deliberately reshaping that learning environment.
-
Self-efficacy: low academic self-efficacy predicts higher propensity towards dishonesty (Bandura, 1994; Murdock et al., 2001), positioning the counsellor as a confidence-builder rather than a disciplinarian.
-
Reinforcement and modelling: behaviour modelled positively and left unpunished is likelier to be repeated, which directs attention towards the normative peer environment as a primary site of intervention.
Together these point towards an approach that is cognitive, behavioural, and social at once, mapping onto the competency domains school counselling frameworks identify as central to practice (Borders & Drury, 1992). Framed through the social action lens articulated by Ratts et al. (2010), counsellors working at group level are agents of normative change operating between personal cognition and community culture, an expression of counselling’s commitment to social justice rather than an add-on to the professional role. Two qualifications follow. Firstly, CBT and SCT were developed within Western research traditions. Secondly, meta-analytic evidence indicates that psychological interventions are more effective when culturally adapted than when transported unmodified (Hall et al., 2016); the disputation of irrational beliefs and the expectation of open verbal challenge in a group both carry cultural assumptions. These interventions are also not the only defensible foundations for this work, since person-centred, solution-focused, narrative, and systemic approaches offer alternative routes to the same ecological targets.
The Interventions as Social Action Practice
Psychoeducation as Community-Level Informing
Psychoeducation (PE) is a systematic, didactic approach to informing clients about their concerns and their management, promoting understanding and personal agency (Bai et al., 2015). Critically for the social action framing, PE is not therapy in the conventional sense; it is education delivered through counselling, aimed at changing the informational and normative landscape within which decisions are made. Bauml et al. (2006) identified its objectives as learning about the problem, facilitating informed management, and improving adherence to prosocial alternatives.
In the present study, the PE intervention consisted of six weekly two-hour group sessions with 17 first year secondary school (SS1) students. Session one established group norms and introduced the concept of proneness to academic dishonesty, the tendency and disposition towards dishonest academic behaviour. Sessions two and three addressed the factual ecology of academic dishonesty: its prevalence in Nigerian schools, its consequences (academic, legal, professional, and social), and the specific trigger conditions that increase vulnerability (peer pressure, poor preparation, inadequate time management). Session four focused on practical skill-building: communication skills, assertiveness training, and problem-solving strategies to manage academic demands without resorting to academic dishonesty. Sessions five and six consolidated learning through practice and the development of personal integrity plans.
The social action character of this work lies in its explicit challenge to community norms. The counsellor intervenes in the peer group’s normative environment by informing students, in a setting where peers witness each other’s engagement, that dishonesty is not victimless, that its consequences extend to the whole educational community, and that honest alternatives are achievable. This aligns with the potential that Gerrity and DeLucia-Waack (2007) identified in psychoeducational group work for at-risk students, improving cognitive, social, and coping skills within a supportive peer environment.
Cognitive Restructuring as Individual and Social Transformation
Cognitive restructuring (CR), a cornerstone of CBT, helps clients identify, challenge, and replace distorted thought patterns with more rational alternatives (Clark, 2014). The distortions targeted here include rationalisation (“I have no choice”), minimisation (“it is not serious”), diffusion of responsibility (“everyone does it”), and pessimistic self-attribution (“I am not smart enough to pass honestly”).
In the present study, the CR intervention was delivered to 23 SS1 students across the same six-week format. Session one established the intervention framework and built group rapport. Session two used a structured self-assessment exercise to examine the personal and environmental factors contributing to proneness to academic dishonesty. Session three introduced Albert Ellis’s A-B-C-D-E-F model (activating event, belief, consequence, disputation, effect, and new feeling) as a framework for mediating between irrational and rational responses to academic pressure (Ellis & Dryden, 2007). Session four deployed specific CR techniques, including Socratic questioning, cognitive imagery, and decatastrophising methods for examining and testing the validity of thoughts that justify academic dishonesty (Beck, 2011; Clark, 2014). Session five worked through the four steps of cognitive restructuring practice: identifying automatic thoughts, labelling cognitive distortions, challenging them rationally, and constructing honest alternative responses (Clark, 2014; Stallard, 2002). Session six reviewed all prior sessions and rehearsed the application of skills to examination scenarios.
Framed as social action, CR is not merely an individual technique but a mechanism for normative shift. When adolescents publicly identify and challenge their own rationales in a group, they simultaneously challenge the peer group’s shared cognitive norms, and others may witness and adopt that work. In ecological terms, this is intervention at the level of Bronfenbrenner’s (1979) microsystem, where a school counsellor has the most direct leverage. The study measured individual-level outcomes only and did not assess group normative change, so this reading is advanced as theoretically grounded rather than demonstrated.
Method
Research Design
A quasi-experimental pre-test/post-test control group design was adopted. This design is appropriate for research on school counselling interventions in naturalistic settings where full randomisation is neither practicable nor ethically advisable (Shadish et al., 2002). Three groups were formed: Experimental Group 1 (PE), Experimental Group 2 (CR), and a control group that received no therapeutic content but participated in a time- and attention-matched placebo condition described below in “Data Collection and Analysis”. Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA) was used to control for pre-test differences, consistent with established practice in educational intervention research (Field, 2018).
Participants and Setting
Participants were drawn from the SS1 population (target N = 11,850) across three public secondary schools in Ilorin metropolis, Kwara State, one selected purposively from each of the three Local Government Areas. Baseline screening with the Proneness to Academic Cheating Behaviours Questionnaire (PACBQ) identified students in the high-proneness category (scores 61–100), from whom 60 were purposively selected: 17 to PE (9 male, 8 female), 23 to CR (11 male, 12 female), and 20 to the control group (10 male, 10 female), as set out in Table 1. Each condition was located in a separate school to prevent contamination, since an intervention working partly by shifting peer norms is vulnerable to diffusion where students share classrooms and peer networks; the implications are considered. SS1 students were selected as representing middle adolescence, when peer influence makes students particularly susceptible to normative dishonesty and most amenable to counselling intervention (World Health Organization, 2021).
Instruments
Two validated instruments were used. The Proneness to Academic Cheating Behaviours Questionnaire (PACBQ), adapted from Salehi and Gholampour (2021), consisted of 20 items rated on a 5-point Likert scale (Always = 5; Never = 1), with reliability coefficient r = .89. A higher score indicates greater proneness to academic dishonesty. The Academic Self-Efficacy Scale, adapted from Gafoor and Ashraf (2006), comprised 25 items (r = .90). A higher score indicates greater academic self-efficacy. A favourable outcome is therefore a decrease on the PACBQ and an increase on the Academic Self-Efficacy Scale. Both instruments were subjected to content validity review by five academics in the Department of Educational Foundations, University of Lagos, and test-retest reliability was established through administration to 20 non-participant SS1 students at a two-week interval.
Data Collection and Analysis
Ethical clearance and institutional permission were obtained from the Kwara State Ministry of Education and participating schools, and written parental consent and student assent were obtained for all participants. Two trained research assistants, Master’s students in Guidance and Counselling at the University of Ilorin, supported instrument administration. Both treatment groups participated in their respective interventions, which consisted of six weekly sessions lasting two hours each.
The control group was matched to the treatment groups for contact time, group size, setting, and facilitator, meeting for six weekly two-hour sessions over the same period. These consisted of structured but non-therapeutic discussions of general school-life themes unrelated to academic integrity, cognition, or study behaviour, containing none of the active ingredients of either intervention: no information about dishonesty or its consequences, no communication, assertiveness, time-management, or study-skills training, no work on cognitive distortions, and no integrity planning. The condition held constant the non-specific effects of group participation, adult attention, and repeated assessment, and guarded against compensatory rivalry. Because it was matched on these features and stripped of intervention content, the group differences reported in the results section cannot readily be attributed to unintended therapeutic activity in the control sessions or to the non-specific benefits of meeting as a group.
Post-test administration followed immediately upon completion of the intervention phase. Data were analysed by one-way Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA), with pre-test scores entered as the covariate to adjust for baseline differences. Where the omnibus test was significant, post-hoc pairwise comparisons were conducted using the least significant difference procedure. Gender was examined by entering gender and the Group × Gender interaction term into separate ANCOVA models for each of the two outcome variables. All hypotheses were tested at the .05 alpha level.
Results
Effect on Proneness to Academic Dishonesty
Table 2 presents pre-test and post-test means for proneness to academic dishonesty. Pre-test means were comparable across the three groups, confirming baseline equivalence, and at post-test both treatment groups showed substantial reductions while the control group was essentially unchanged.
ANCOVA confirmed that the group differences were statistically significant (F[15, 3] = 3.115, p = .032). Post-hoc pairwise comparisons using the least significant difference procedure indicated that the psychoeducation group (MD = 4.691, p = .034) and the cognitive restructuring group (MD = 3.691, p = .042) each differed significantly from the control group, while the difference between the two treatment groups was not significant (p > .05). H01 was therefore rejected.
Both interventions therefore produced a reliable reduction in students’ disposition towards academic dishonesty, while the disposition of the control group remained unchanged across the same period. Neither approach outperformed the other, indicating that psychoeducation and cognitive restructuring are broadly interchangeable in their effect on this outcome at the scale examined here. For practice, this means a counsellor may select whichever modality better matches their training and competence without expecting a loss of effectiveness, a point developed below in “Why Both Interventions Worked for Proneness to Academic Dishonesty”.
Effect on Academic Self-Efficacy
Table 3 presents pre-test and post-test means for academic self-efficacy. Both treatment groups showed substantial increases relative to baseline, while the control group declined. ANCOVA confirmed a significant group effect (F[12, 6] = 8.035, p = .009), and pairwise comparisons indicated that each treatment group differed significantly from the control group (PE: MD = −21.73, p = .042; CR: MD = −16.20, p = .049). H02 was rejected.
Both interventions therefore strengthened students’ belief in their own academic competence, and did so against a control group whose self-efficacy fell slightly over the same period. The direction of that contrast matters: students in the treatment groups did not merely hold their position but improved on it, while those receiving no therapeutic content drifted downwards across a school term. Given the established inverse relationship between academic self-efficacy and proneness to dishonesty (Murdock et al., 2001; Umaru, 2013), this gain is unlikely to be incidental to the reduction reported in the previous section, a possibility taken up below in “Self-Efficacy as the Mechanism of Change”.
Gender as a Moderator
Gender was examined for each outcome by entering gender and the Group × Gender interaction term into the ANCOVA models alongside the pre-test covariate. For proneness to academic dishonesty, the main effect of gender was not significant, F(1, 53) = 0.84, p = .364, indicating that male and female students did not differ in adjusted post-test proneness, and the Group × Gender interaction was likewise non-significant, F(2, 53) = 1.17, p = .318, indicating that the effect of treatment condition on proneness did not differ by gender. The same pattern held for academic self-efficacy, where neither the main effect of gender, F(1, 3) = 0.44, p = .555, nor the interaction, F(2, 3) = 2.73, p = .211, reached significance. Table 4 summarises these results, and H03 was retained.
Both interventions therefore operated comparably for male and female participants, with neither the level of either outcome nor the magnitude of the treatment effect depending on gender. This should not be read as establishing equivalence between male and female students, since a non-significant test does not demonstrate the absence of a difference, and the gender subgroups here are small enough that only sizeable interactions would have been detected. Descriptively, the largest self-efficacy gains varied by group rather than favouring either sex consistently, being larger for male participants in the psychoeducation group and for female participants in the cognitive restructuring group, though neither difference was statistically reliable. These results are interpreted further in “Interpreting the Absence of Gender Differences”.
Discussion
Why Both Interventions Worked for Proneness to Academic Dishonesty
The significant reduction in proneness to academic dishonesty across both experimental groups is the headline finding, and it carries empirical and social action significance alike. It provides evidence that structured group counselling can shift students’ disposition towards dishonesty, consistent with Anyamene et al. (2015), who found psychoeducation reduced examination misconduct tendencies among Nigerian secondary students, and Tamami et al. (2015), whose combined psychoeducation and relaxation program reduced dishonest behaviour among Indonesian high school students. Kurniasari et al. (2021) similarly reported that cognitive restructuring group counselling reduced dishonesty and raised self-efficacy, reinforcing the cross-contextual generalisability of these mechanisms.
The mechanisms are theoretically coherent. PE works by raising awareness: students who understand the academic, legal, social, and professional consequences of dishonesty, and who hold alternative coping strategies in time management, study skills, and assertiveness are better placed to resist the situational pressures that trigger it. CR works by disrupting the cognitive architecture that makes dishonesty seem reasonable; once students recognise their rationalisations as distortions rather than truths, those rationalisations lose their motivational force. Ghamari-Kivi et al. (2015) demonstrated a parallel mechanism in finding cognitive restructuring more effective than study-skills training alone in reducing test anxiety.
That PE and CR did not differ significantly suggests both are viable tools for this population and need not be treated as mutually exclusive. In resource-constrained settings this flexibility matters: a counsellor more competent in group psychoeducation can achieve outcomes comparable to one more proficient in cognitive restructuring.
For practice, these findings carry specific implications, and it is worth distinguishing what follows directly from the data from what is extrapolated from theory. The data validate structured, manualised group programs as a legitimate format for counsellors addressing academic integrity, an important affirmation where counsellors face pressure to confine themselves to individual reactive support; and the comparable effectiveness of the two modalities means counsellors can select the one matching their training without compromising outcomes. The six-session format fits school timetables, though this is a property of the design rather than a result. The group format is itself an intervention rather than a delivery mechanism: convening students to examine shared rationalisations and rehearse integrity-supporting behaviours is the social learning environment SCT identifies as most powerful for normative change (Bandura, 1977), operating at the microsystem level (Bronfenbrenner, 1979). This last point is an inference from theory rather than a finding, since the study included no group-level normative measure; it is offered as a proposition for future research.
Self-Efficacy as the Mechanism of Change
The significant improvement in self-efficacy is not merely an additional positive finding; it is likely the mechanism through which the reduction in dishonesty occurs. The inverse relationship between academic self-efficacy and propensity towards dishonesty is well established. Students who believe they can succeed legitimately have less motivation to cheat (Barzegar & Khezri, 2012; Finn & Frone, 2004; Pratiwi, 2014). By building self-efficacy, PE and CR address both the root cause, the belief that honest effort is insufficient, and the symptom. Kurniasari et al. (2021) corroborated this, finding self-efficacy gains from cognitive restructuring directly associated with reductions in dishonest behaviour, suggesting a mediating pathway that future research should test explicitly.
This has implications for how counsellors frame, design, and advocate for their work. In framing, sessions positioned primarily as “anti-cheating” may carry a negative and potentially stigmatising message. Whereas, reframing them as confidence-building and academic empowerment is theoretically congruent with the self-efficacy mechanism and plausibly likelier to secure buy-in from students, staff, and parents. The study did not manipulate or measure framing, so the suggestion that deficit-oriented framing provokes defensiveness or resistance is a practice-informed hypothesis rather than a finding. The underlying rationale is nonetheless well supported: framing shapes the therapeutic alliance, consistently among the strongest predictors of counselling outcome (Norcross & Lambert, 2011).
In design, the finding directs counsellors to ensure every session contains an explicit component building belief in academic competence. Bandura’s (1994) four sources of efficacy belief offer a practical template: mastery experience, through structured opportunities to succeed at manageable tasks; vicarious experience, through exposure to peers who have navigated academic pressure honestly, which the group format supplies at no cost; verbal persuasion and reattribution, connecting past successes to ability and effort rather than luck; and attention to physiological and affective states, the source most often omitted, since examination anxiety is readily misread as evidence of incompetence. In advocacy, these data give counsellors an evidence-based case for the preventive value of group programs, and for counselling as a contributor to achievement rather than a disciplinary support service.
Interpreting the Absence of Gender Differences
That gender neither exerted a main effect nor moderated treatment effects warrants more careful interpretation than a bare statement of null results allows, given the body of research reporting gender differences in academic dishonesty (Isiaka, 2026; Isiaka et al., 2023). What these analyses can support must be established first. A non-significant interaction is not evidence of equivalence: with each treatment group further divided by gender, the resulting subgroups are small enough that the models have limited power to detect interactions of modest size. The correct reading is that this study found no evidence of gender moderation, not that it demonstrated its absence.
Several considerations nonetheless make an attenuated gender gap plausible here. The sample was purposively selected for high proneness, which truncates variance and removes precisely the students at low and moderate proneness among whom gender differences are most visible in the wider literature (Isiaka, 2025). The measures also index disposition rather than the frequency of dishonest behaviour, and Whitley et al. (1999) found in meta-analysis that gender differences in attitudes were considerably smaller and less consistent than in reported behaviour; Salehi and Gholampour (2021), whose scale this instrument adapts, likewise reported no significant gender effect. Finally, the ecological argument carries an implication for gender easily overlooked: where the drivers are predominantly structural, those pressures bear on male and female students in the same coeducational classrooms at close to equal intensity, so a null result is what the framework would predict rather than an anomaly.
The divergence from studies reporting higher male rates should also be read against what those studies sampled. Anderman and Midgley (2004) examined United States students across the middle-to-high-school transition and Nazir et al. (2011) surveyed Pakistani business undergraduates, both differing from the present sample in age, level, setting, and measurement. Social desirability may also operate differentially by gender in self-report designs. The present data do not permit adjudication between these explanations.
The practical implication should be stated conservatively. These findings give no basis for gender-differentiated versions of the protocols for comparable high-proneness groups, which is a weaker and more defensible claim than asserting that gender is irrelevant to intervention design. Adequately powered replication, treating gender as a planned moderator and sampling across the full range of proneness, is required before any firmer conclusion.
Social Action Implications: From the Counsellor’s Room to Educational Policy
School Counsellors as Advocates for Academic Integrity
The evidence from this study, modest in scale but clear in direction, supports positioning school counsellors as frontline advocates for academic integrity. Advocacy cannot stop at the group level, however. If dishonesty is partly a product of overcrowded classrooms, inadequate preparation time, permissive peer networks, and institutional tolerance of malpractice, counsellors must advocate for changes to those conditions as well as to student cognition.
Counsellors are well placed to encourage school administrations to create Academic Integrity Committees: cross-functional bodies of counsellors, teachers, students, and parents responsible for designing and monitoring the school’s integrity environment. The counsellor’s contribution is best understood as consultative, collaborative, and preventive rather than disciplinary. Professional ethical frameworks are explicit that the counsellor’s primary obligation is to the student and that counselling should be differentiated from investigative and sanctioning functions (American School Counselor Association, 2022). A counsellor who helps determine penalties risks forfeiting the trust on which disclosure depends, in relation to a behaviour students have strong reasons to conceal. Within those boundaries, the contribution is substantial: evidence-based knowledge of what drives dishonesty and what reduces it, prevention design and delivery, staff and parent education, and advocacy for the structural conditions that make integrity viable. This is advocacy within the systems change and community collaboration domains of established counsellor frameworks (Toporek et al., 2009), rather than activism.
Integrating PE and CR into National School Counselling Programs
The Nigerian Federal Ministry of Education’s school counselling guidelines currently lack specific provisions for structured group interventions targeting examination malpractice. Given the levels of misconduct documented in Nigerian secondary schools (Aderinto et al., 2021; International Centre for Investigative Reporting, 2026), the absence of evidence-based counselling protocols represents a significant policy gap, which this study provides preliminary justification for addressing.
I recommend that the Federal Ministry of Education, in partnership with the Association of Professional Counsellors in Nigeria (APROCON) and the Counselling Association of Nigeria (CASSON), develop a national psychoeducation and cognitive restructuring protocol targeting academic dishonesty, to be piloted and formally evaluated within the secondary school counselling curriculum. The present study produced significant short-term reductions in proneness and gains in self-efficacy within a single term, in one metropolis and with 60 participants, and provides a replicable template that could be standardised, packaged with training materials, and tested at larger scale. I stop deliberately short of recommending immediate mandatory national adoption: a single quasi-experimental study with 60 purposively selected participants, self-report measures, and no follow-up provides promising preliminary support, not the evidentiary base that compulsory implementation across 36 states would require. The appropriate next step is multi-site replication with randomisation where ethically feasible, adequate power, and behavioural follow-up.
Beyond the school level, the Kwara State Ministry of Education and its counterparts in other states should allocate specific budget lines for the training of school counsellors in evidence-based group intervention techniques. The intervention described here required only a trained counsellor, six weeks, and a group space, a minimal resource investment relative to the documented scale of the malpractice problem.
Partnering with Examination Bodies
WAEC and the National Examinations Council (NECO) possess institutional authority over secondary-level examinations and have demonstrated willingness to take punitive action against malpractice, the 2022 indictment of Kwara State school principals being one illustration (Adebayo, 2022). However, punitive enforcement alone is insufficient: Eckstein (2003) documented that punitive measures without accompanying educational interventions produce minimal long-term reduction in examination fraud. I recommend that WAEC and NECO formally partner with counselling associations to fund and deliver pre-examination psychoeducational programs in registered schools, a form of demand-side prevention that complements supply-side enforcement.
Addressing Parents and Community as Social Action Partners
This study’s finding that self-efficacy improved significantly across both treatment groups points to the importance of extending the self-efficacy message beyond the school. Parents who prioritise grades over genuine learning, and who knowingly or unknowingly create pressure environments that make academic dishonesty rational, are participants in the ecology of malpractice (Lang, 2013). Community-level psychoeducation that extends to parent groups, through parent-teacher associations and community outreach events, would address this neglected dimension. Tamami et al. (2015) demonstrated that psychoeducation directed at both students and their parents produced greater reductions in academically dishonest behaviour than student-only interventions, a finding that counsellors in Nigeria should urgently incorporate into their advocacy for comprehensive, family-inclusive integrity programs.
Transferability and Implications for School Counsellors Globally
This paper is grounded in a specific context: Nigerian public secondary schools, a setting of acute structural pressure, high rates of malpractice, and a counselling profession still consolidating its evidence base. That specificity is an analytical strength rather than a concession, since context-rich research supplies ecological detail that decontextualised studies cannot. The question is not whether the Nigerian context is universal, which it is not, but whether the mechanisms and intervention logic documented here apply beyond it. The evidence suggests that in substantial part they do, subject to the constraints set out below.
Three bases for transferability can be identified. The first is theoretical: both interventions rest on CBT and SCT, frameworks internationally validated and foundational to school counselling practice (Borders & Drury, 1992; Christner et al., 2007). The intervention logic depends not on anything specific to Nigeria but on the CBT premise that cognitive distortions sustain maladaptive behaviour and the SCT premise that self-efficacy and observational learning shape behavioural choice. These premises are advanced within their parent theories as general psychological processes and supported across a wide range of settings, although that evidence base is unevenly distributed and the degree of cultural adaptation required varies (Hall et al., 2016). The second is ecological: as documented above in “The Social Ecology of Academic Dishonesty”, the structural drivers are cross-contextual, documented in the Gulf (Al-Dossary, 2017), Ethiopia (Dejene, 2021), Southeast Asia (Diego, 2017), and North Africa (Hammoudi & Benzerroug, 2021), with Cizek (2003) identifying the same convergence in Western contexts. The third is practical: the six-session model requires only a trained counsellor, a group of students, a private space, and six weeks within a term, making it potentially replicable across a wide range of contexts, including under-resourced schools where the pressures generating dishonesty are often most acute.
There are limits to transferability that intellectual honesty requires acknowledging. Session content, the consequences cited, the peer examples, and the institutional referents will need contextual adaptation, and the six-session format may need adjusting to different timetables. The instruments were validated primarily within Nigerian and similar contexts, so local validation is advisable elsewhere. The social action framing will also resonate differently where counsellors occupy different institutional roles.
Three further constraints bear directly on whether a counsellor elsewhere could do what this paper recommends. The first is theoretical orientation. The argument assumes a counsellor willing to work within cognitive-behavioural and social-cognitive frameworks. However, school counsellors are not uniformly CBT-oriented. Person-centred, solution-focused, narrative, systemic, psychodynamic, and integrative counselling positions are all well represented in school counselling, and practitioners working from these positions may find the proposed protocols uncongenial even while accepting the ecological analysis. The mechanisms identified here—reducing rationalisation, building efficacy, and shifting peer norms—are addressable from more than one orientation; a solution-focused counsellor might pursue them through exception-finding and scaling questions, a narrative counsellor through externalising conversations about examination pressure. The interventions reported here are one worked example of a broader argument rather than the only route to it.
The second constraint is ecological difference. “The Social Ecology of Academic Dishonesty” above emphasised commonalities, and that emphasis is warranted, but commonality is not equivalence. Assessment stakes, class sizes, invigilation regimes, the detectability of technology-assisted dishonesty, the cultural meaning of certification, family pressure, and the legitimacy accorded to school authority all vary substantially between systems. A school where dishonesty is individually opportunistic and institutionally penalised presents a materially different problem from one where it is organised, widely tolerated, and, in places, facilitated by staff. The Nigerian case sits closer to the second, and interventions calibrated to it will not map automatically onto the first. In lower-pressure systems the balance would shift towards individual cognitive work and away from structural advocacy, and where authority relations differ, the group disputation methods central to CR may need substantial adaptation.
The third constraint, in practice the most limiting, is professional role and resourcing. The framework assumes a counsellor with the mandate, time, training, and standing to run six two-hour group sessions and sit on a policy committee, and that assumption does not hold universally. Counsellor-to-student ratios in many systems far exceed recommended levels, and the post is often combined with teaching, careers guidance, or administration. There is also a substantive distinction between the school guidance counsellor role, oriented towards educational and careers support, and the school counsellor role oriented towards mental health provision. The former may hold curricular access and a whole-cohort remit but limited training in cognitive techniques; the latter the clinical training but a caseload of higher-acuity referrals, leaving little capacity for prevention. Where integrity work falls outside the counsellor’s recognised remit, the binding constraint is mandate rather than skill. The claim properly advanced here is, therefore, that school counsellors can be effective agents of change where conditions permit, and that those conditions are worth arguing for, not that school counsellors everywhere are positioned to lead such change.
What is transferable is more fundamental than any of these features: the argument that school counsellors, equipped with structured, theoretically grounded group interventions, can shift the cognitive norms and efficacy beliefs that make academic dishonesty likely, and that, in doing so, they perform social action rather than merely deliver a service. That argument does not belong to Nigeria. It belongs to the profession.
Conclusion: Counselling as Social Transformation
The counsellor who walks into a group room with a six-session PE or CR program aimed at reducing proneness to academic dishonesty is not simply treating a behavioural problem. That counsellor is performing social action: challenging the cognitive norms that sustain dishonesty, building the self-efficacy that makes integrity viable, reshaping the peer normative environment, and equipping students to navigate academic pressure without resorting to fraud. The argument is grounded in a Nigerian study, but the professional identity it describes is not a Nigerian construct.
The empirical evidence is modest in scale but consistent in direction: psychoeducation and cognitive restructuring both significantly reduced proneness to academic dishonesty and improved self-efficacy among Nigerian SS1 students. These findings join evidence from Anyamene et al. (2015) in Nigeria, Tamami et al. (2015) and Kurniasari et al. (2021) in Indonesia, and Ghamari-Kivi et al. (2015) in Iran, that group counselling grounded in CBT and SCT can shift the conditions that make dishonesty likely across diverse contexts. That consistency reflects the fact that the psychological architecture of dishonesty—distorted thinking, low self-efficacy, and peer normalisation—is not culturally specific, and neither are the tools designed to address it.
Individual-level change is nonetheless insufficient while the structural conditions generating dishonesty remain intact. The social action mandate requires moving beyond the group room: advocating in school committees, engaging examination bodies and governance structures, influencing policy, and educating families. Academic dishonesty is a community problem that no individual-level intervention alone can dismantle. School counsellors, positioned between individual psychology and social environment, are well placed to contribute to the response and, where mandate and resourcing allow, to help lead it in partnership with teachers, school leaders, examination bodies, and families. Leadership of a systemic and collaborative response is not the property of any single profession. The counsellor described here is not a specialist or an outlier but a practitioner enacting the profession’s core commitments: promoting human dignity, building individual capacity, and challenging the systemic conditions that constrain it.
